Class 2: Discussion Notes

Ancient and Medieval

Aristotle

  • Focus on substance and change
  • Structure of the “Universe”
    • Essentially concentric zones largely defined by elements
  • Properties
    • Wet – Dry; Cold – Hot
    • Primary building blocks of matter
    • May be mixed in various proportions
  • Elements
    • Combinations of Properties
    • General categories: Air, Fire, Water, Earth
    • Variation in each domain due to exact mixture
  • Exhalations
    • Wet and Dry
    • Result from the sun’s rays (heat) interacting with water and earth
    • Move elements/properties around; explain various atmospheric observations
  •  Anima
    • Animating “force”
    • Gradient of different anima: vegetative, sensitive, rational

Generation of Stones

  • Aristotle
    • Earth’s rays heat up the earth to produce dry exhalations
    • Exhalations move through earth and interact with other earths
    • Recombine to make new earths
    • Can harden material: clay into rock
  • Petrific Seed
    • Low level of vegetative anima leads toward changes such as decay or growth; here result in the generation of new stones
    • Heat penetrates earth and forms dry exhalations that move below the surface
    • Recombines and flows to surface where it forms new stones under the influence of anima
  • Lapidifying Juice
    • “Succus” moves through the earth interior and acts to form stones as it interacts with materials, picks up heat or cools, etc.
    • It also flows through animals and humans (forms gallstones)
    • Different types of juice postulated to explain different kinds of stones
  • Common examples
    • Caves, stalagmites and stalactities
    • Bands in rocks

Figured Stones

  • Problem is the geometric forms of “earths”
  • Plato stress on idealized forms provides a mental framework
  • “Correspondences” in that same shapes are imprinted on various substances
  • Influenced debates about “fossils” (anything dug up)